|
Please note:
The following information has been sent to me and gathered from
different sources. There is some conflicting information on Diaphone
types as well as PSI and CFM numbers. In these cases, this info
should serve only as a reference, and not taken as the gospel so
to speak. We would hate to hear of any damage caused to these great
horns, and we in no way accept any responsibility for any damages
that do occur.
According to Gamewell literature, a Type B Diaphone operates on 35 PSI and 1.2 cubic feet per second of free
air.
Mike Maderia, President of Maderia Warning
Systems, Garwood NJ says...
I run ours at about 48 psi. I want to make sure that I
hear it when I am sleeping and I can.”
Adam Smith notes "Variance in sound is a factor of the horn's
condition (how well maintained) and the supply of air. At different
feed pressures, a Gamewell horn will have different pitch and
timbre. At the pressure where the piston's motor frequency and
the horn's natural frequency are the same, the horn is in tune
and has a smooth mellow note like an air horn. It higher pressures,
they have a harsh, more siren-like timbre. With too little air
pressure, the piston frequency drops below the horn's natural
resonance, and it becomes really flabby and inefficient, sounding
like a fart (sorry!). Different sounds come about as the period
of the piston goes in and out of phase with the natural resonant
frequency of the horn projector. The resonating column of air
in the projector exerts a force on the piston that definitely
coerces it towards the horn's natural frequency. But too much
air pressure, and the natural period of the piston's motor section
becomes dominant, at which point the piston alone is setting
the pitch, and the horn is not operating in a resonant condition
anymore. As with any other kind of air horn or whistle, this
is called "overblowing". Some stations have more than one horn,
which is especially common here in Massachusetts, where 2-4
horns per station is typical. In this case, the horns are never
quite in tune with each other, and there is always a strong
'beat frequency' that pulses at a rate which is the difference(s)
in pitch between the two (or more) horns. For example, if one
horn is barking at 400 Hz, and another is 405Hz, there will
be a strong and audible 5Hz throbbing."
Adam
also makes a note about compressors for operating Diaphones.
He says "A piston compressor with a huge air reservoir
is what was chosen for use with Gamewell diaphone horns, despite
huge tank size and limited reserves of air. Certainly these
days, a screw compressor would be the obvious choice for driving
Gamewell diaphones, providing 35-40 psi steadily at the required
flow rate of 75 CFM."
Jim
Armstrong has 2 complete Diaphones up and running that
he obtained several years ago. Jim recently wrote this to me....
"I came
across two horns about a year and a half ago; they had been purchased
at an auction in a locked box, sort of blind. Several people
had fooled around trying to get some noise out of them, with no
success. It took a month or so of looking for sounding specs
before I got an old sheet from the Gamewell. The problem,
of course, was the pressure and the volume of air needed; it didn't
help that both pistons were seized up and I didn't know if they
were supposed to spin or reciprocate. Finally, I used the captive
air tank from a water system and a 1" ball valve; after
many tries, I just about knocked my shoes off. Of course the time
it decided to sound was the first time I tried without hearing
protection. I now have both horns working loudly and whenever I
want, with a good-sized tank (tiny, by Gamewell standards) and a
good air regulator; they are about 10 feet over my garage on a 1"
galvy pipe."
"They work
best if they work regularly; periods of inactivity will result in
sour notes when re-honked. The nasty "blat" is most often a symptom
of over-pressure; the later horns came with a tag that says "45
PSI MAX), but I have found that 35 works a whole lot better and
has to be easier on the piston (try finding one of THOSE puppies).
When I was blowing two horns on one pipe (i.e. all inputs the same
for both horns) there was almost no "beat" or overtone. I'm always
surprised that even 25 PSI toots sound about the same, so I'm not
sure about the pitch/pressure relationship. There were both brass
and aluminum pistons made and they definitely produce different
sounds, with the heavier brass being deeper. And
any numbers other than A22908? Finally, the exquisite interior machining
of the brass throat also varies from early to later horns, changing
from slots to holes. And if you ever have trouble with your first
blast, try placing the piston at its rear-most position. I usually
rotate and move it in and out to make sure it's free."
SAFETY FIRST!
From Adam Smith
Many folks have repurposed LP tanks for
air receivers. But, any mechanical engineer will tell you not to,
and for a number of reasons.
The other reasons LPG tanks are not advised are primarily design
issues, they are designed to be discharged very slowly and their
design does not account for metal fatigue from rapid
depressurization. Air tanks are designed to withstand repeated rapid
evacuation. This has come up many, many times in
rec.crafts.metalworking. Also, the drain is only half the rust
issue--propane tanks are not built with corrosion allowance
accounted for in the wall thickness. Even if you drain the tank
after each use, there is still moisture coating the walls. As the
walls rust, they present even more surface area for moisture to
cling to. Propane and LP gas do not have moisture in them,
compressed air always does.
Next, what temperature is that 250PSI rating specified at?
Compressed air can reach 300-350F very easily, and ASME specifies
that air receiver Max allowable pressure ratings are taken at 475F.
Be aware that your LP tank with a 250 PSI rating may give you some
false security in that seemingly high number if it's only counting
ambient earth temperatures (120 degrees or so).
When Horn & Whistle did their compressed air safety article, the
consensus of the experts was pretty straight forward: use an ASME
code air receiver for air, the extra $200 or so spent for a solid
rated air tank is worth it where your life is at stake.
Page Last Modified 11/17/11 11:01
This
site designed and maintained by
Copyright ©
1998 - 2012 - Morgan Communications.
All Rights Reserved
|